The Competitive Advantage of Tax Planning
Abstract
Does corporate tax planning create a substantial competitive advantage, as many believe? This paper examines the advantage’s existence, magnitude, and persistence. I find that corporate tax planning innovations, proxied by net decreases in effective tax rates, do contribute to excess shareholder returns (returns above the cost of capital), indicating that the advantage exists. However, the absolute magnitude of these excess returns is modest, far smaller than the nominal tax savings. Compared with other indicators of successful business strategies, tax planning innovations have smaller factor loadings and account for less variation in excess returns. Sales growth alone explains more than seven times as much of the variation in excess returns as tax planning does. Even reductions in interest expense, an indicator of capital restructuring that prior research finds difficult to achieve, outperform tax planning. Nor does the advantage persist: firms’ cash effective tax rates converge in the long run. Overall, tax planning is an essential part of corporate strategy, but on average not a significant source of competitive advantage.
What explains variation in excess returns?
Longer bars indicate greater relative importance. Select a concept for details.
- Tax planning: 0.5% of explained variation Variable: DCETR1 Reduction in cash taxes paid relative to pretax income compared with the prior year. A larger reduction represents more tax planning savings.
- Pretax profitability: 2.8% of explained variation Variable: BTPM1 Operating profit before taxes as a percentage of sales.
- Sales growth: 9.3% of explained variation Variable: Growth1 Percentage increase in sales compared with the prior year.
- Innovation: 2.2% of explained variation Variable: ΔINNOV Increase in the estimated market value of the firm’s newly granted patents relative to its assets.
- Additional savings in cost of goods sold: 10.7% of explained variation Variable: ΔCOGS Additional savings from reducing cost of goods sold as a percentage of sales compared with the prior year.
- Additional selling & administrative savings: 6.0% of explained variation Variable: ΔSG&A Additional savings from reducing selling and administrative expenses as a percentage of sales compared with the prior year.
- Additional interest-expense savings: 0.9% of explained variation Variable: ΔXINT Additional savings from reducing interest expense as a percentage of sales compared with the prior year.
View exact chart data and definitions
Method details: Bar length shows each concept’s share of the variation in excess returns explained by the analysis; it indicates relative importance, not whether an effect is positive or negative. The analysis uses the full one-year specification with year and industry fixed effects and controls for changes in R&D and advertising intensity.
| Concept | Variable | Share of explained variation | Definition |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tax planning | DCETR1 | 0.5% | Reduction in cash taxes paid relative to pretax income compared with the prior year. A larger reduction represents more tax planning savings. |
| Pretax profitability | BTPM1 | 2.8% | Operating profit before taxes as a percentage of sales. |
| Sales growth | Growth1 | 9.3% | Percentage increase in sales compared with the prior year. |
| Innovation | ΔINNOV | 2.2% | Increase in the estimated market value of the firm’s newly granted patents relative to its assets. |
| Additional savings in cost of goods sold | ΔCOGS | 10.7% | Additional savings from reducing cost of goods sold as a percentage of sales compared with the prior year. |
| Additional selling & administrative savings | ΔSG&A | 6.0% | Additional savings from reducing selling and administrative expenses as a percentage of sales compared with the prior year. |
| Additional interest-expense savings | ΔXINT | 0.9% | Additional savings from reducing interest expense as a percentage of sales compared with the prior year. |
Keywords: Corporate tax planning, Competitive advantage, Rate of return, Valuation, Tax Cuts and Jobs Act
Recommended citation: Pan, Gang (Ernest). 2024. "The Competitive Advantage of Tax Planning." Working Paper.